Skip Navigation Links Home » Federal Superfund » Silver Bow Creek/Butte Area Stream Side Tailings

Silver Bow Creek/Stream Side Tailings

 

 Silver Bow Creek map  

Ospray and Fish, Photo taken by Don MacGee

Summer 2011

 Picture of boy with trout

Young angler, Rye Vincent, holding 18.5 inch cutthroat trout catch from Siver Bow Creek just below Miles Crossing bridge.

Summer 2010

 2009 mink return to SBC This mink was seen along Silver Bow Creek in September 2009.

Mink prey on fish so the presence of mink indicates a return of fish to the stream.

The tabs below provide link to information about Silver Bow Creek/Streamside Tailings.

The cleanup of Silver Bow Creek has been ongoing since 1999 as part of a Superfund remedial action being coordinated by the Montana Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) in consultation with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). In 2000, the Natural Resource Damage Program (NRDP) of the Montana Department of Justice formed a partnership with DEQ, bringing a restoration component to the project that goes beyond remediation required under Superfund. Provided below is a brief history of the project, updates regarding the current status of the project, and descriptions of activities planned in future years.

PROJECT BACKGROUND

The Problem
Silver Bow Creek extends from Butte approximately 23 miles to the Warm Springs Ponds, a water treatment facility located at the headwaters of the Clark Fork River (see corridor map). Since the late 1800s, tailings and other mine wastes containing elevated concentrations of metals have been discharged to or otherwise entered Silver Bow Creek. These toxic discharges impacted the stream and floodplain with heavy metals and virtually eliminated aquatic life in the stream. Tailings deposited in the floodplain are toxic to plants and have resulted in a floodplain that is largely devoid of vegetation and is generally incapable of supporting wildlife. In 1983, EPA listed the Silver Bow Creek/Butte area as one of multiple Superfund sites in the Upper Clark Fork River Basin. The agency later designated the approximately 23 stream miles of streamside tailings along Silver Bow Creek as an operable unit (OU) within this overall Superfund site. The Streamside Tailings Operable Unit (SSTOU) has become one of the areas of focus for Superfund cleanup in the Butte area. Initially, EPA named ARCO as the primary party responsible for remediation of the SSTOU and other Superfund sites in the Upper Clark Fork Basin through its acquisition of the Anaconda Company. EPA and DEQ issued a Record of Decision (ROD) for the site in November 1995 that identifies the final site remedy and the agencies' rationale for selecting that remedy. The major remedial action that resulted from issuance of the ROD is excavation of tailings and related impacted soils from the floodplain of Silver Bow Creek and reconstruction of the stream channel and floodplain. For planning purposes, the SSTOU was divided into four subareas, each with a distinct geologic and geographic character.

The Natural Resources Damage Program (NRDP) Connection. In a 1999 state, federal and tribal settlement, ARCO agreed to pay $215 million to the State to resolve certain claims. From the settlement amount, $80 million plus interest was set aside for DEQ and EPA to implement the remedy for Silver Bow Creek. Some of the remaining amount is being used to enhance the cleanup of Silver Bow Creek through various habitat improvements and restoration actions. DEQ and EPA are coordinating the cleanup of the Silver Bow Creek remedy with NRDP.

 

 

Restoration Economy

An Estimation of Montana’s Restoration Economy, September 2009. This study estimates the economic benefits from remediation and restoration by completing a case study on the Silver Bow Creek Superfund site in the Upper Clark Fork Basin to determine what types and how many jobs are involved in the restoration industry. One finding indicates that 31 jobs and $2.59 million in economic activity are created for every million dollars of funding spent on remediation and restoration.

 

 Montana Governor Brian Schweitzer Montana Governor Brian Schweitzer joined legendary fly fisher Bud Lilly   

The fishery has returned to an area that was once a dead zone where nothing could live. On May 21, 2012, to mark this milestone, Montana Governor BrianSchweitzer joined legendary fly fisher Bud Lilly for a “Fish in the Creek” ceremony where they cast a few fly lines.

 

 

 

 New story Map On-Line

Click on the link to see an interactive Map of all the Updates to Silver Bow creek.

 

Subarea
Description
 

Subarea 1


1999-2003 Reaches A-E, constructed and re-vegetated
Reach A ~ 1 river mile, 36.6 acres, 166,562 cubic yards
Reaches B&C ~2 river miles, 58 acres, 347,253 cubic yards
Reaches D&E ~2 river miles, 54.8 acres, 252,939 cubic yards
Subarea 2

2004 Reach F constructed and re-vegetated, ~ 1 river mile, 44 acres
2005 Reach G constructed and re-vegetated, ~ 1 river mile, 86 acres
2006 Reach H constructed and re-vegetated, ~ 1 river mile, 96 acres
Total of 1,258,013 yards removed from F,G and H
2008 Reach I and J, constructed & regulated ~ 2 river miles,
163 acres 519,398 yards

Subarea 3

2011 Reach K, Constructed 282,584 c.y. ~ 1 River Mile
2012 Reach L, Constructed 58,000 c.y. Tailings ~ 1 River Mile

Reach M-O, Construction in progress

 

Subarea 4 2003 Reach R Parcel 152 constructed, 103,064 cubic yards, 53 acres re-vegetated 2004-2005 Reach R Phase 1 constructed, 252,270 cubic yards, 173 acres re-vegetated 2005 Reach R Phase 2 constructed, 359,782 cubic yards, 102 acres re-vegetated 2006 Reach Q Phases 3 and 4 constructed, 333,088 cubic yards, 138 acres re-vegetated
2007 Phase 5, installation of instream sediment pond
2008-2009 Phase 6 & 7 Reach P + Q ~ 4.3 river miles, 277 Acres,
534,223 cubic yards tailings removed
2011-2012 Phase 8, Reach R + S; 3.4 miles of stream channel,
544,772 cubic yards of tailings removed; 250 acres re-vegetated
2012-2013 Phase 9 Reach T under construction - 1.9 miles of
stream channel; 403,556  cubic yards tailings to be removed;
and 122 acres of floodplain regrading and re-vegetating.
Estimates to Date
90% of Tailings/Impacted Soils Removed
80% of Stream Channel Reconstructed
Cost: $20.57 per cubic yard - Includes all remediation
expenses i.e. design, construction, weed control,
re-vegetation, monitoring, overhead, etc.

 

 

EPA Superfund
Cleanup
Process
PA/SI NPL
Listing
RI/FS ROD RD/RA Construction
Completion
Post
Construction
Completion
NPL
Delete
Reuse
Stream Side Tailings C C C C C O TBD TBD TBD

 

Table Legend
Symbol Symbol Id
C Complete
O Ongoing
I Interim
N Negotiations
D Deferred
TBD To Be Determined

  

There is ongoing construction taking place in both Subarea 3 and Subarea 4.

 

 

Montana Department of Environmental Quality Link    
Remediation Division Link The Natural Resource Damage Program (NRDP)  
EPA Superfund Program Silver Bow Creek/Butte Area Link  
Download Adobe Reader
 
 

 

EPA Region 8 Superfund Program Contacts MT DEQ Logo
Kristine Edwards Joel Chavez
Remedial Project Manager
U.S. EPA, Montana Office
10 West 15th Street, Suite 3200
Helena, MT 59626
406-457-5021
edwards.kristine@epa.gov
Project Officer
P.O. Box 200901
Helena MT  59620-0901
406-841-5031
1-800-246-8098 (in-state only)
jchavez@mt.gov